Best Restaurants in North Beach CA: A Local’s Guide to the Best Eats in Little Italy

North Beach has always held a special place in San Francisco’s story. From its Gold Rush grit to its rise as the city’s Little Italy, this neighborhood has evolved into a beloved pocket of cafés, bakeries, seafood counters, trattorias, and legendary pizza shops.

For more than a decade, our team at Dylan’s Tours has worked, eaten, and explored right here in North Beach. Our office sits on Columbus Avenue, so we spend our days guiding guests through San Francisco’s scenic neighborhoods and then pointing them to our favorite spots for dinner just steps away.

Whether you’re craving cioppino, carbonara, crispy focaccia, wood-fired pizza, gnocchi with classic tomato sauce, or tiramisu, San Francisco’s Little Italy has something that hits the spot.

Below, you’ll discover the best restaurants located in San Francisco’s North Beach, from iconic institutions that helped define the neighborhood to newer arrivals that earned a loyal following.

If you’re exploring the city, pair your meal with Dylan’s Famous Tour or one of our Open-Air City Tours. It’s a fun, easy way to see San Francisco like a local before settling in for a great dinner in North Beach.

1. Sotto Mare — A Classic North Beach Restaurant for Seafood and Cioppino

• Since 2003 
• TripAdvisor: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
• What to try: “The Best Damn Crab Cioppino!” Sotto Mare is famous for it!

If you like seafood, you’re in luck! Plenty of San Francisco Restaurants serve amazing seafood since the city is practically an island after all.

However, finding true San Francisco cioppino restaurants can be tricky. If this is what you’re looking for, we recommend Sotto Mare Oysteria and Seafood in the heart of the North Beach Italian restaurant scene. You won’t find a better cioppino anywhere in San Francisco! Sotto Mare also has arguably the best oysters in the city.

Sotto Mare is Italian for “under the sea”. Since they only serve seafood, you know it must be good.

What is Cioppino?

Never heard of cioppino? Cioppino is the true San Francisco treat (sorry Rice-a-Roni). It was created during the Gold Rush Era.

Cioppino originated on the boats of Italian fishermen who would stay out in open water until they had a full catch to bring home. For safety and comradery, these Italian crabbers, fishermen, and oystercatchers all moored together in the evening and “chipped in” some of their daily catch. The result was a unique type of seafood soup.

Why Sotto Mare Is Known for the Best Cioppino in San Francisco

What makes the cioppino at Sotto Mare San Francisco so unique? This family-owned North Beach Italian restaurant is run by a husband and wife duo. And the recipe for this savory soup comes straight from Richie, the owner’s, own grandmother.

When Rich asked his Nona for the recipe, he was surprised to learn she didn’t actually have one. She had always made her cioppino from memory. After experimenting in the kitchen with his Nona, the cioppino at Sotto Mare was perfected.

We consider this to be the absolute best cioppino in San Francisco. You’ll find a mix of Dungeness Crab, calamari, shrimp, oysters, and muscles. It’s all mixed together in a red sauce served on a bed of penne pasta.

Even the bread at Sotto Mare Oysteria & Seafood is connected to Richie’s Nona! Famed sourdough bread creator, Boudin Bakery, attempted to partner with Sotto Mare to be their bread provider. Richie would only agree if Boudin could make an exact replica of his Nona’s Italian bread.

So, if you’ve ever had Italian bread from Boudin’s Bakery, you’ve already had a little taste from this North Beach Italian restaurant. Now it’s time to try their cioppino!

You’ll only be able to make a Sotto Mare reservation if you have a group of 4 or more. So, if you want to skip the line at Sotto Mare Oysteria & Seafood bring a few friends with you. 

Pro Tip: Many of our guests stop here after taking one of our Private Open-Air City Tours, since it’s an easy walk from our North Beach office and one of the most memorable ways to end a day of exploring San Francisco.

2. Tommaso’s — An Old-School Italian Restaurant With the Oldest Brick Oven in the Bay Area

• Since 1935 
• TripAdvisor: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
• What to try: Pizza, with pepperonis imported from Italy and cooked in the first brick oven on the West Coast.

Tommaso’s first earned a faithful following as one of the best Italian restaurants in Little Italy after they introduced the brick oven to the West Coast in 1935.

Back then, this North Beach Italian restaurant was known as Lupo’s. The original owners, the Cantalupo family, immigrated from Naples and brought their wood-fired brick oven with them.

Beautifully painted murals from 1935 decorate the walls of this stalwart North Beach Italian restaurant. The paintings depict stunning views from the Amalfi Coast. Rumor has it, the Cantalupo’s paid the artist in spaghetti and meatballs!

Along with some of the best pizza in San Francisco, Tommaso’s offers up some tasty North Beach Italian seafood options.

Regulars include Agostino’s good friend Francis Ford Coppola, along with Coppola’s daughter Sophia and his nephew, Nicolas Cage. Former San Francisco mayors and California governors make guest appearances at this iconic North Beach Italian restaurant, as well.

The Story Behind the Tommaso’s Name

In the early 70s, the restaurant was handed over to the longtime cook who had been with Lupo’s since the beginning. The Cantalupo family gave their cook the restaurant. But, they didn’t want him to use the name.

Running an authentic Italian restaurant with a very non-Italian name concerned the new owner and longtime chef, Tommy Chin. So Tommy Italian-ized his name and dubbed this beloved North Beach Italian restaurant Tommaso’s.

Shortly after this name change, the business switched hands one last time. This time, it was bought by the Crotti family.

The Crotti’s, a brother and sister duo, were recent immigrants from Italy. They kept the name and the menu while making little changes throughout the years.

If you’re exploring the area between meals, don’t miss our guide to the 50 Things to Do in San Francisco. It’s filled with local favorites and easy ways to plan a full day in the city.

3. Tony’s Pizza Napoletana — Award-Winning Pizza Napoletana in the Heart of Little Italy

• Since 2009 
• TripAdvisor: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
• What to try: Margherita pizza. It took home the 2007 World Pizza Cup in Naples!

San Francisco pizza might not be as internationally recognized as New York pizza. But, if there’s anyone trying to change that it would be Tony Gemignani of Tony’s Pizza Napoletana.

Tony Gemignani has made notable winnings at the World Pizza Cup and at the World Championship of Pizza Makers (yes, those are both real things). He was the first American to win these pizza awards in Italy. Since then, he has helped Tony’s Pizza earn a reputation as the best pizzeria in San Francisco.

Tony’s isn’t just known as one of the best pizza places in SF. This restaurant is also TripAdvisor’s #5 pizza place in the United States!

Despite the misleading name, Tony’s has a diverse Italian menu complete with a full-service bar. Oftentimes, you can find Tony Gemignani himself baking pizzas in the kitchen. And yes, he’ll be baking your pizza with the same Cirigliano Wood Burning Oven that helped him win all those pizza competitions.

4. Firenze By Night — Classic Italian Comfort and Homemade Pasta

• Since 1987
• TripAdvisor: ⭐⭐⭐⭐
• What to try: Homemade gnocchi, veal saltimbocca, and any of their house-made pastas

Firenze By Night has been a North Beach favorite for nearly four decades, known for warm hospitality, generous portions, and classic Tuscan-style pasta dishes. It’s the kind of restaurant where the menu feels familiar in all the right ways — rich red sauces, velvety cream pastas, tender veal, and gnocchi that tastes like it came straight from an Italian grandmother’s kitchen.

The dining room is cozy and welcoming, making it a great choice for date nights, families, or anyone craving an authentic Italian meal in Little Italy. The service is warm, the flavors are comforting, and the prices are friendlier than many newer restaurants in the neighborhood.

If you’re planning ahead, it’s a good idea to make a reservation, especially on weekends. For visitors exploring North Beach after a city tour, Firenze By Night is one of the best places to settle in for a classic Italian dinner with real neighborhood charm.

5. Italian Homemade Company — Fresh Pasta and a Relaxed Neighborhood Vibe

• Since 2014 
• TripAdvisor: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
• What to try: Fresh tortellini with prosciutto, mortadella, pork and parmigiana

The Italian Homemade Company is comparatively a recent addition to North Beach Italian restaurants in San Francisco. But, that’s no reason to overlook this new kid on the block!

The husband (Mattia) and wife (Alice) duo behind Italian Homemade moved to San Francisco just a year before opening this restaurant. Now, it is a beloved local chain of Italian restaurants in San Francisco.

As you might have guessed from the name, the specialty here is homemade pasta and sauces.

Italian Homemade Co. offers a new casual take on traditional dining in Little Italy. You can mix and match your choice of homemade pasta and homemade sauces for a personalized dining experience.

Take advantage of their dry goods section to pick up a truly unique, and tasty, San Francisco souvenir. Then when you get back home, attempt to recreate some recipes from this local favorite restaurant!

6. Fior d’Italia — Historic North Beach Dining With Classic Italian Flavor

• Since 1886 
• TripAdvisor: ⭐⭐⭐⭐
• What to try: Petto di Pollo alla Valdostana (chicken breast sauteed with prosciutto and fontina cheese)

Fior d’Italia has been considered the preeminent North Beach Italian restaurant since they first started dishing out food in May of 1886. Fior d’Italia is more than the oldest Italian restaurant in San Francisco. It is the oldest Italian restaurant in America!

Over the past 132 years, this iconic North Beach Italian restaurant has had seven different locations and burnt down three times. One of the times Fior d’Italia burnt down was during the Great Fires & Earthquake of 1906 that destroyed much of San Francisco.

After the earthquake, the restaurant reopened the very next day from a tent to feed the hungry refugees of San Francisco. Fior d’Italia continued dishing out Italian food from their makeshift tent-restaurant for a year before finding a new location in North Beach.

Fior d’Italia’s longest stint at a location was on the corner of Washington Square Park. They were here for over 50 years until a fire destroyed most of the restaurant in 2005. San Franciscans watched as their most cherished North Beach Italian restaurant had been lost to the flames.

Fortunately, Fior d’Italia reemerged in the historic San Remo Hotel.

You can now enjoy some of the best oysters in San Francisco and a large selection of Italian seafood appetizers and entrees. Nothing compares to enjoying fine cuisine at the oldest Italian restaurant in San Francisco.

7. Original Joe’s — A Warm Italian Dining Experience With Classic Lasagna

• Since 1937 
• TripAdvisor: ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
• What to try: House-made baked lasagna

Original Joe’s first opened in the once working-class neighborhood of The Tenderloin in 1937. This first location only had room for 14 stools at the counter. But that didn’t stop it from becoming a much-loved local’s choice for Italian food in San Francisco.

The restaurant had an innovative interior layout and style. Known as “Joe’s Concept”, it was characterized by leather booths, big portions, and friendly waiters in tuxedos. The name of “Joe’s Concept” was never copyrighted. So, as a result, many similar restaurants have opened across America over the years.

San Francisco’s Tenderloin neighborhood began to change as public rehabilitation centers and health facilities closed throughout California in the 70s. Due to this, the homeless population increased in the Tenderloin. Despite the changes in the Tenderloin, Original Joe’s maintained its reputation as one of the best Italian restaurants in San Francisco.

That is until this famed San Francisco Italian restaurant caught fire and burned to the ground in 2007. After the fire, the children and grandchildren of the Original Joe’s owner sifted through the rubble for any trace of surviving remnants of the now-destroyed restaurant.

It took five years, but in 2012 Original Joe’s re-emerged. Like a phoenix rising from the ashes, they rebuilt in the former Fior d’Italia location. Which, ironically, also had caught fire and closed in 2005.

Now, located on the corner of Washington Square Park in Little Italy, Original Joe’s is one of a handful of the best North Beach Italian restaurants

Big windows facing the park are perfect for people-watching in the heart of Little Italy. Walls decorated with signage pulled from the rubble of the original location make for a unique dining experience.

8. Tosca Cafe – A North Beach Icon for Authentic Italian Dishes and Cocktails

• Since 1919 
• TripAdvisor: ⭐⭐⭐⭐
• What to try: Rigatoni with beef and pork ragu, topped with aged provolone cheese

Tosca Cafe might not be the oldest North Beach Italian restaurant, but it is one of the most historic. Even if it technically started off as a speakeasy.

In 1918, the United States instituted a constitutional ban on making, transporting, and ingesting alcoholic beverages.

A year later Tosca “Cafe” opened in San Francisco and introduced the espresso machine to the West Coast. At the same time, they debuted their famous San Francisco cocktail. It was called the “House Cappuccino”, and it did not have any espresso in it.

Even after the prohibition was lifted, Tosca remained a prominent player in the thriving scene of restaurants on Columbus Avenue.

Fans of Tosca included a wide array of celebrities. Here you could find the Beatniks of the 50s, Hunter S. Thompson of “Fear and Loathing” fame, Bono from U2, world-renowned ballet dancer Rudolph Nureyev, a slew of San Francisco mayors, Metallica, Kid Rock, and actor Sean Penn.

When rumors began to circulate that Tosca was over 100k in debt and ready to shut its doors for good, longtime regular Sean Penn stepped in.

Penn portrayed Harvey Milk in the award-winning biopic about San Francisco’s first openly gay politician. When he heard about Tosca’s trouble, he “reached out to restaurateur Ken Friedman and chef April Bloomfield, the team behind New York’s The Spotted Pig, imploring them to save the place.”

As a result, what was once one of San Francisco’s best dive bars has become one of the best North Beach Italian restaurants in SF!

9. Caffe Trieste — Espresso, Cannoli, and Classic Italian Atmosphere

• Since 1956
• TripAdvisor: ⭐⭐⭐⭐
• What to try: Classic espresso drinks and the house-made cannoli

Caffe Trieste is one of the most beloved institutions in North Beach, and stepping inside feels like entering a living piece of San Francisco history. Opened in 1956, it was the first espresso house on the West Coast, and it quickly became a gathering place for artists, poets, musicians, and neighborhood regulars.

If you want a true Little Italy café experience, this is the place for it. Order a cappuccino, an espresso pulled the old-school way, or a cannoli from the pastry case and find a table near the window. The café walls are covered in photographs of famous visitors — including Francis Ford Coppola, who reportedly wrote parts of The Godfather screenplay here.

The atmosphere is warm, familiar, and comfortably nostalgic. Locals chat with the baristas, musicians sometimes perform in the corner, and the tables spill out onto the sidewalk on sunny afternoons. It’s the perfect stop before or after exploring the neighborhood, and it’s an essential part of any list of the best North Beach restaurants and cafés.

If you’re craving a simple, authentic Italian moment — espresso in hand, cannoli on the side — Caffe Trieste captures the heart of Little Italy like no other.

10. Hilda and Jesse — A Modern, Michelin-Starred Dining Experience in North Beach

• Since 2021
• Michelin Star: ⭐ (awarded in 2024 and retained in 2025)
• What to try: Pancakes Without Boundaries, Chef’s Adventure tasting menu, seasonal brunch plates

Hilda and Jesse brings a completely different energy to North Beach — bright, playful, creative, and proudly modern. Co-owners Rachel Sillcocks and Chef Ollie Liedags have built a restaurant centered around “fun luxury,” and their approach has earned them a Michelin star and a reputation as one of the most exciting dining experiences in the neighborhood.

The menu blends fine-dining technique with unexpected twists, especially during brunch, where dishes like the famous Pancakes Without Boundaries feel both comforting and elevated. In the evening, the Chef’s Adventure Menu highlights seasonal ingredients in a five-course progression that changes often and showcases some of the most precise cooking in the area.

The dining room feels cheerful and intentional — striped walls, checkered floors, and a welcoming team that delivers some of the best service in San Francisco. It’s the kind of restaurant where the details matter and every plate feels like a small celebration.

If you’re looking for a modern restaurant in North Beach that pairs creativity with warm hospitality, Hilda and Jesse is one of the best choices in the entire neighborhood. Reservations are highly recommended, especially on weekends.

Explore North Beach and Beyond With Dylan’s Tours

North Beach is one of those neighborhoods that feels even richer when you understand the stories behind it — the Gold Rush streets, the Italian roots, the cafés that inspired artists, and the restaurants that shaped San Francisco’s North Beach food culture.

One of the easiest ways to experience all of that is by starting your day with a Dylan’s tour and ending it with a great meal right here in Little Italy.

Our office sits on Columbus Avenue, so whether you’re joining Dylan’s Famous Tour or booking one of our Private Open-Air City Tours, you’ll begin your adventure in the heart of North Beach. 

If you want to explore San Francisco like a local — and eat like one too — we’d love to show you around.

Ready to plan your adventure? Explore our epic San Francisco tours and make North Beach the start of a day you’ll remember.